Hathaway and Clarkson were in the middle of a game of “Sing That Name That Tune,” which required them to quickly identify songs by their instrumentals and start singing them as soon as they recognized them.
Hathaway was leading the game, beating Clarkson to name the Billy Joel classic "Piano Man," as well as Hanson's late '90s hit "MMMBop."
Comedian and "American Ninja Warrior" host Matt Iseman, who was hosting the game, joked that Hathaway "will be doing a Kelly Clarkson tribute show in Vegas,” to which Clarkson replied, “Should I just quit?”